|
Happy Tuesday! This week is about money you earn, money you leave behind, and money you probably shouldn’t have kept.
|
|
We’re debunking a bracket myth, reading the fine print on “unlimited” PTO, and building a checklist for anyone leaving a job on any terms. Then we close with a guy who embezzled $738,000 and told the Supreme Court he shouldn’t owe tax on it.
|
|
Let’s get to it.
|
|
|
|
This week’s lineup:
|
-
💰 The raise you’re afraid to take (and shouldn’t be)
-
🏖️ “Unlimited” PTO has a catch nobody mentions at the offer stage
-
❌ What quitting, getting laid off, or getting fired does to your taxes
-
⚖️ He stole $738,000 and told the Supreme Court it wasn’t taxable. Bold move.
|
|
|
| |
Tax Strategies
|
💰 The bracket myth that’s talking people out of taking raises
|
|
|
|
The Quick & Bristly: A raise can never shrink your paycheck. Federal tax brackets are marginal — only the income above each threshold gets taxed at the higher rate. For 2026, single filers hit 24% at $105,701 and 32% at $201,776; married filing jointly hits those rates at $211,401 and $403,551. Worry about your withholding, not your bracket.
|
|
|
|
Stop us if you’ve heard this one before: your coworker is turning down a raise because they “don’t want to get bumped into a higher tax bracket.” First of all, Brad, that’s not how any of this works, and second, it’s costing you real money.
|
How marginal brackets actually work
|
|
U.S. income tax is layered, like the worst cake known to man. Each chunk of income is taxed at its own rate:
|
-
10% on income up to $12,400 (single) / $24,800 (married filing jointly)
-
12% up to $50,400 / $100,800
-
22% up to $105,700 / $211,400
-
24%, 32%, 35%, 37% follow, topping out above $640,600 / $768,700
|
|
A raise from $100,000 to $110,000 doesn’t tax your whole salary at a new rate — only the slice above $105,701 gets taxed at 24%. Everything below stays exactly where it was.
|
|
The mix-up? People confuse their marginal rate (the rate on their last dollar) with their effective rate (the blended average across everything). Nobody pays their marginal rate on their entire salary.
|
What you should actually do
|
-
Update your W-4 if the raise is substantial, especially alongside a bonus, RSU vesting, or side income
-
Check phase-outs — QBI deduction, IRA deduction limits, certain credits — since a higher salary can nudge you into a phase-out range
-
Take the raise. The bracket panic is a myth; the withholding question is the real one.
|
|
👉 Check where your income falls on the 2026 bracket table
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
PRESENTED BY THE RAMEN HUSTLE
|
Free PDF: 45 crazy side hustles worth stealing
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Six questions, pulled straight from this week’s issue. No studying, no spreadsheet, no idea why you suddenly remember the standard mileage rate at parties now. Whoever racks up the most right answers earns a spot on the leaderboard and the right to be insufferable about it.
|
|
Click below, to get started. If you haven’t played before, you’ll need to enter some basic info that is only used for the quiz. Good luck, and may the tax knowledge be ever in your favor.
|
|
👉 Take the quiz →
|
| |
Personal Finance
|
🏖️ Why unlimited PTO isn’t the miracle you think it is
|
|
|
|
The Quick & Bristly: “Unlimited PTO” often means no payout when you leave, because there’s no accrued balance to pay out — that’s frequently the point for the employer. If your PTO does get paid out, it’s taxed as supplemental wages, usually at a flat 22% federal rate.
|
|
|
|
Unlimited PTO sounds like the kind of job perk Santa Claus would dream up — until, of course, you leave said job and cold, hard reality hits.
|
|
The no-limits time off policy has become increasingly popular, with companies like Netflix and Coinbase offering it to attract top talent. But is it really all it’s cracked up to be? Let’s break it down.
|
What HR doesn’t tell you during onboarding
|
|
Traditional PTO accrues — you earn hours per pay period, they build up in a bucket, and in roughly 20 states, that bucket is legally treated as earned wages your employer must pay out when you leave.
|
|
Unlimited PTO doesn’t accrue. There’s no bucket. No balance means nothing owed — even in states with mandatory payout laws, because those laws apply to accrued time specifically.
|
|
And just in case you’re curious, this isn’t an employer oversight: not having to pay out PTO is a big part of why companies like these policies.
|
If a payout does happen
|
|
Some companies pay out unused time anyway, as a courtesy or under a hybrid policy. When that happens:
|
-
The IRS treats it as supplemental wages, the same bucket as bonuses and commissions
-
Paid separately from your regular check, it can be withheld at a flat 22% federal rate, plus 6.2% Social Security and 1.45% Medicare
-
That withholding isn’t your final tax rate — it’s just the up-front cut, so you may see some back (or owe more) at filing
|
What you should do
|
|
Before you sign an offer with “unlimited PTO” as a headline perk, ask what happens to unused time at separation. The answer tells you whether it’s generosity or good marketing.
|
|
👉 See which states require PTO payout at separation
|
|
|
|
|
Planning your exit? Start with your resume.
|
|
|
|
Already picturing life after that “unlimited PTO” job? Might be time to plan your exit properly. Resume.io helps you put together a resume that actually gets you noticed — no hidden catches, no fine print.
|
|
👉 Build yours free today
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Every Thursday, we go to work.
|
|
The TaxStache Business Edition is built for owners and operators. Quick hits on entity structure, quarterly deadlines, deduction strategy and the IRS rule changes that actually affect your bottom line. Plus a weekly download you can put to use the same afternoon.
|
|
If you run a business (or you’re building one), Thursday is definitely your day.
|
Would you like to receive our Thursday Business Edition?
|
|
|
| |
Wacky Tax Tales
|
⚖️ He stole $738,000, then tried to convince the Supreme Court it was basically a loan
|
 |
|
Image by Andres M.
|
|
|
The Quick and Bristly: Union official Eugene James embezzled more than $738,000 between 1951 and 1954, reported none of it, and when the IRS came knocking, argued that stolen money couldn’t be taxable since he was legally obligated to give it back. The Supreme Court did not find this persuasive. James v. United States (1961) settled it: money is taxable the moment you treat it as your own, legally entitled to it or not.
|
|
|
|
Somewhere, a tax attorney is still shaking their head at how close this argument came to working.
|
What happened
|
|
Eugene James, a labor union official with apparently more confidence than judgment, embezzled over $738,000 from his union and its insurer across four years and reported exactly none of it on his taxes.
|
|
When prosecutors caught up with him, his lawyers didn’t argue he hadn’t taken the money — they argued the money was never really “income” in the first place, since an embezzler is legally obligated to return what he steals, kind of like an extremely aggressive, unauthorized loan. There was even prior Supreme Court precedent backing him up: Commissioner v. Wilcox (1946) had said exactly this.
|
The Court’s response, roughly translated
|
|
The Supreme Court looked at this argument, looked at the concept of “stealing $738,000 and calling it a loan,” and said, politely but firmly: no.
|
|
In James v. United States, the Court threw out its own prior ruling and held that:
|
-
Money is taxable the second you receive it and treat it as yours — legal right to it or not
-
“I might have to give it back eventually” doesn’t get you out of owing tax on it now
-
This is the modern “claim of right” doctrine, and it’s still very much the law
|
|
James’s conviction got tossed anyway, on a technicality about relying on the old rule before it flipped — so justice, in the karmic sense, took its time. But the tax principle survived fully intact.
|
The far more boring version of this story
|
|
You will, hopefully, never embezzle $738,000. But the same rule quietly governs something almost everyone runs into: your employer accidentally overpaying you.
|
-
That extra money is taxable the year you got it, whether you meant to keep it or not
-
Fix it the same calendar year, and your employer just corrects your W-2 — no drama
-
Fix it the next year, and you’re stuck repaying the full gross amount, then clawing back the tax
|
|
The moral? The IRS has never once asked, “But did you deserve this money?” It only asks whether you had it.
|
|
👉 Read the dirty details
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
The quick (and slightly prickly) stories we didn’t have time to get to:
|
|
|
|
If you made it this far, you’re our kind of nerd. Hit reply and tell us which story you want us to dive deeper into next week.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Follow us for even more great tips, tricks, and deadline reminders. Facebook | Instagram | LinkedIn
|
|
|
|
|
|