When you pay your insurance premiums every month, you expect your insurer to hold up its end of the bargain. But suddenly, your insurer decides your medical care is someone else’s financial problem, and you get the dreaded denial letter.
Fortunately, a denial isn’t necessarily the final answer, and you have the right to challenge it.
Claim denied? Here’s what that actually means
A denied claim means your insurer has refused to pay for all or part of a medical service. But that doesn’t automatically mean you’re responsible for the entire bill.
Insurance companies have plenty of reasons for saying no. Some are legitimate. Others might come down to a missing digit on your paperwork. Here’s what might be behind your denial:
- Billing or coding errors
- Missing information
- Out-of-network services
- Treatments your insurer doesn’t consider medically necessary
Before you start drafting an angry email (tempting, we know), check your denial notice or Explanation of Benefits (EOB). It should tell you why your claim was denied and how to appeal.
Sometimes, fixing a billing mistake is all it takes. Other times, you’ll need to make your case. And if your insurer still won’t budget, that’s when you bring in reinforcements.
Get more articles like this straight to your inbox 
Free as a meme, easy to bail anytime.
How to appeal a denied health insurance claim
The first step is usually filing an internal appeal. Yes, you’re asking the same company that denied your claim to reconsider its decision. It’s a little like asking someone to grade their own test, but it’s an important first step.
Under standard federal rules, you usually have 180 days from receiving your denial notice to file. Here’s what to do:
- Follow the instructions. Include your insurance information, claim number, and an explanation of why you’re appealing.
- Bring the receipts. Medical records, your EOB, and a letter from your doctor can help support your case.
- Document everything. Keep copies of submissions, emails, and notes from phone calls.
Insurers usually have 30 days to decide standard appeals for care you haven’t received and 60 days for care you’ve already received.
Still denied? You have options
If your insurer rejects your appeal, you may qualify for an external review. This time, an independent reviewer who doesn’t work for your insurance company evaluates your case. Finally, a second opinion that doesn’t come from the same people who said no the first time.
For eligible denials, you usually have four months to request an external review. If the external review overturns the denial, your insurer must accept the decision. And if waiting could seriously jeopardize your health, ask about an expedited review.
Getting a denial letter doesn’t mean you should just pull out your wallet and pay. Check the reason, gather your evidence, and appeal before the deadline. Your insurance company may have the first word, but that doesn’t mean it gets the last.
